We Were Here Together is best suited to two players who want a communication-led puzzle adventure and are happy to work through challenges that critics have sometimes found unintuitive. Its cooperative design is the main draw; the story may be less compelling, and the game’s appeal depends heavily on enjoying the experience with your partner.
What kind of game is We Were Here Together?
We Were Here Together is a two-player cooperative puzzle adventure from Total Mayhem Games and the third entry in the We Were Here series. The official game page describes it as a co-op adventure, while Steam lists online co-op and puzzle tags. The game launched on October 10, 2019, according to its Steam listing.
The central idea is to solve puzzles together while coordinating across separate player perspectives. That makes communication and partner compatibility part of the experience, rather than an optional extra: it is a better fit for two people who want to describe what they see, compare clues and act in coordination than for someone looking for a solo puzzle game.
What do reviews say about the puzzles and story?
Co-op design is the strongest point
Critic summaries on Metacritic praise puzzles tailored to two-player cooperation. That design gives both players a reason to communicate and contribute, which is the game’s clearest strength for fans of collaborative problem-solving.
#1 Best Overall
- WE’RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS Couples Edition includes 150 conversation cards with 3 carefully crafted levels of questions and wildcards. Find out how well you already know each other and reveal the layers you never knew existed.
- PERCEPTION - How well do you know your partner? In Level 1, gain perspective on how your significant other sees you and challenge the assumptions you make about each other. There’s only one rule: Be honest.
- CONNECTION - Who are you, really? Level 2 is full of rarely asked questions that help you connect on a deeper level with your partner for a more memorable date night experience.
- REFLECTION - In Level 3, couples reflect on what they’ve learned about each other and themselves. What did playing teach you about your partner? What did it teach you about yourself?
- WHAT’S INSIDE - 150 conversation cards and wildcards to encourage players to open up even more. A 2-player game for couples in any stage of their relationship, whether they’ve just made it official or have been together forever. Ages 15+ Warning: may unlock honest answers.
Some puzzles may feel unclear or demanding
The same critic coverage includes reservations that some puzzles can feel unintuitive or overly complex. These are review judgments, not a guarantee that every pair will get stuck; however, players who prefer direct instructions or quick, frictionless solutions may find the puzzle approach less satisfying.
The story may not carry the same weight
One critic summary praised the co-op puzzles while criticizing the story. The available reviews therefore point to a game whose strongest case is its shared puzzle-solving, rather than a narrative that will necessarily be the main attraction.
Rank #2
- WE’RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS Kids Edition is a purpose-driven card game all about empowering meaningful connections. It features three carefully crafted levels of conversation cards and wildcards, making it one of the ultimate card games for kids and adults who love games. Perfect for game nights and parties.
- PERCEPTION - Do you know how others see you? In Level 1, players gain perspective on what first impressions they give off and challenge the assumptions they make about others. Meaningful conversations with kids start here.
- CONNECTION - Who are you, really? Level 2 is full of rarely asked questions that help you connect on a deeper level, making this a standout favorite among kids card games and making game night the best night of the week.
- REFLECTION - In Level 3, all players reflect on what they’ve learned about each other and themselves from having such funny, honest, and thoughtful conversations together. This game night gem is the perfect catalyst for endless fun and bonding.
- WHAT’S INSIDE - 150 conversation cards for kids and wildcards, WNRS notepad, 2 rainbow-colored pencils, and 2 “Why” cards, which encourage players to open up even more and strengthen their relationships. For 2-6 players, ages 5+. Warning: feelings may arise.
What are the review scores?
These are dated platform snapshots, not permanent ratings. Steam’s indexed listing showed 82% positive from 4,974 English user reviews on October 8, 2026. Metacritic showed a 77 Metascore from six critic reviews and a 7.3 user score from 110 ratings on the same date. Metacritic’s critic summary counted four positive and two mixed reviews, with no negative reviews among those six at that snapshot.
The critic sample is small, and Metacritic scores can differ by platform. Neither an aggregate score nor a broad user rating can predict how a particular pair will respond to the puzzles or to playing together.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Rank #3
- WE’RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS is a purpose driven card game all about empowering meaningful connections & relationships. Three carefully crafted levels of conversation cards & wildcards for adults & teens who love games. Perfect for game nights & parties.
- PERCEPTION - Do you know how others see you? In Level 1, players gain perspective on what first impressions they give off & challenge the assumptions they make about others. Meaningful conversations with strangers, friends & families starts here.
- CONNECTION - Who are you, really? Level 2 is full of rarely asked questions that help you connect on a deeper level with your friends, family, or partner, making game night or date night the best night of the week.
- REFLECTION - In Level 3, all players reflect on what they’ve learned about each other and themselves from having such funny, honest, and thoughtful conversations together. This game night gem is the perfect catalyst for endless fun & bonding.
- WHAT’S INSIDE - 150 conversation cards and wildcards, WNRS notepad, 2 pencils, and 2 Transparent “Dig Deeper” cards, which are meant to encourage players to open up even more. For 2-6 players Ages 15+. Warning: feelings may arise.
Can you play across platforms?
Total Mayhem Games lists PC, PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo Switch on its official game page and says cross-platform gameplay is supported. Check the exact store listing and cross-play compatibility for both players’ platforms before buying: the available information does not establish every platform-specific pairing or current storefront availability.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Who is We Were Here Together for?
- A good match: two players seeking an online co-op game built around communication and collaborative puzzles.
- Consider carefully: players who are easily frustrated by unclear clues or puzzles that take time to untangle.
- Look elsewhere if: the main priority is a strong story, solo play, or a low-coordination experience.
The game’s premise makes clear communication useful, but the sources do not establish a particular headset as a requirement. Prices, campaign length and detailed platform-by-platform performance are not established here.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- WE’RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS Family Edition is a purpose-driven card game all about empowering meaningful connections. 3 carefully crafted levels of conversation cards and wildcards for adults and teens who love games. Perfect for game nights and parties.
- PERCEPTION - Do you know how others see you? In Level 1, players gain perspective on what first impressions they give off and challenge the assumptions they make about others. Meaningful conversations with friends, teens, and families start here.
- CONNECTION - Who are you, really? Level 2 is full of rarely asked questions that help you connect on a deeper level with your friends, family, or partner, making Valentine's Day, game night or date night the best night of the week.
- REFLECTION - In Level 3, all players reflect on what they’ve learned about each other and themselves from having such funny, honest, and thoughtful conversations together. This game night gem is the perfect catalyst for endless fun and bonding.
- WHAT’S INSIDE - 150 conversation cards and wildcards, WNRS notepad, 2 pencils, and 2 Transparent “Dig Deeper” cards, which encourage players to open up even more and strengthen their relationships. For 2-6 players, Ages 15+. Warning: feelings may arise.
Rank #4
- A BOLD NEW GAME FROM WE'RE NOT REALLY STRANGERS — with 150 ‘would you rather’ questions that you didn't know you needed to ask. Reveal sides of your friends, your partner, and yourself that you've never seen before.
- THREE CATEGORIES - Use the spinner to let fate decide which deck you pull a card from. Land on LIFE for the big questions, LOVE for relationship dilemmas, or for the answers nobody saw coming. With each conversation starter card, the conversations are guaranteed to go places you didn't expect.
- NO EASY ANSWERS - These questions might feel impossible to answer, and that is by design. Watching other players struggle to choose is half the fun, and the other half is learning more about them, whether you use it as a conversation card couple activity or with a whole group, based on their answers.
- THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE - Don't overthink it. Your first instinct is the most honest one. This game works best when you stop second-guessing and start saying how you really feel for a fun party game or a relationship card game.
- WHAT’S INSIDE - 150 unique ‘would you rather’ question cards divided into three categories, and 1 spinner.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
