Metacritic’s gangster-game coverage spans more than one kind of game: its descriptions include open-world action and crime strategy. But the exact 15-game selection and ranking order behind this title could not be verified, so a numbered list or scores would risk attributing unsupported results to Metacritic.
What Metacritic’s verified examples show
Metacritic describes Grand Theft Auto III as placing players in a gangster-movie-style story set in a three-dimensional city. Its PlayStation 2 ranking page also includes Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas and Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, with descriptions mentioning gang trouble, biker gangs, Cuban gangsters and corrupt politicians. Metacritic’s all-time games page and its PlayStation 2 ranking page establish these games as relevant examples, but not as entries in a verified 15-game gangster ranking.
Two other confirmed examples broaden the genre beyond open-world crime action: Metacritic has dedicated pages for Mafia: Definitive Edition, described in the page excerpt as a story associated with gangster movies, and Empire of Sin, characterized as a gangster-themed game.
Why a Metascore needs its platform and edition
Metacritic can have separate records for different platforms or versions of a game. A score without its platform or edition can therefore be misleading. The available pages do not establish a complete, comparable set of 15 scores, and the excerpts do not provide enough detail to quote scores responsibly. No ranking order or score should be inferred from the examples above.
#1 Best Overall
- 🚗 Command the Streets of Chicago: Compete as rival gang bosses vying for control of city districts. 💼 Drive, Drop, and Dominate: Use cars to move, pick up gangsters, and establish your influence. 🎲 Dynamic Strategy Game: Tactical movement, timing, and bluffing decide who becomes the true King of Chicago. 🎨 Stylish 1920s Artwork: Immersive design and premium Playte-quality components. ⚠️ Ages 14+ | Not a Children’s Toy: Contains small parts; intended for hobby gamers and adults
What remains unverified
The exact source list, the order of its 15 games, the platform or edition used for each Metascore, and the date those scores were checked are not established by the available records. The confirmed titles here demonstrate that gangster themes appear across distinct gameplay styles; they do not reconstruct the titled ranking.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Gangster-Themed Card Game – Lead a rat mafia family in tense auctions for gangsters, valuables, and businesses.
- Card-Driven Strategy – Use bidding cards to compete in over 140 auctions while managing resources and risk.
- Fast-Paced Auctions – Race to outbid rivals, but prepare for hasty sales when the Police arrive!
- Designed by Reiner Knizia – From the world-renowned designer of modern auction classics like Ra and Modern Art.
- Complete Game in a Box – Includes 141 auction cards, bidding cards, scoring markers, reference cards, scoring track, and rulebook.
Rank #4
- HIGH-STAKES HEIST: Join the craziest, foam gun-wielding crooks in this intense board game.
- SECOND EDITION: New art and foam guns for an even more immersive experience.
- BLUFF AND INTIMIDATE: Outsmart your fellow thieves to claim the biggest share of the loot.
- CARTOON AESTHETIC: Enjoy a hilarious and visually stunning atmosphere.
- STRATEGIC LOOT COLLECTION: Collect loot sets in unique ways to maximize your endgame points.
Rank #3
- For 2-5 players
- 90 minute playing time
- Based on the classic Francis Ford Coppola film
- Designed by Eric M. Lang. Artwork by Karl Kopinski
- Plunge into the world of crime, Corruption and the mafia in New York City with this standalone big box board game with high-quality miniatures
Rank #2
- Wise Guys is a quick to learn, cut throat, area control boardgame where you play as one of four rival gangs seeking to strike it rich as “Rum Runners” on the rough streets of Chicago at the height of the roaring 20’s.
- Wheel, deal, and fight to control locations. Buy/sell alcohol, get politicians elected and get help in return or double-cross rival gangs. Negotiate, threaten and ally with them, but beware the inevitable knife in the back…
- Players roll to choose their gang, then set themselves up with a respectable front of neighbourhood business men and their associates, whilst keeping their resources, money, guns & booze hidden from their rivals.
- Taking control of real-life gangsters, such as Al ‘Scarface’ Capone, Dean O’Banion, ‘Polack Joe’ Saltis & Ralph Sheldon, players issue orders for their Made Men & Associates exploiting profitable opportunities as they arise.
- Everything you need to turn Chicago upside down is included in the box. Experience the glitz and glamour of the roaring 20’s as a gang boss in Prohibition-era Chicago!
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.
