All Storyteller Puzzle Answers and Solutions (Complete 14-Chapter Guide)

This guide lists solutions for every puzzle in the current Storyteller release: Chapters 1–13, the Final Chapter: Novels, and the post-Ceremony Devilish variants. Place the named scene in the next panel with the specified characters. Positions such as left, right, edge, cage, grave and bush matter.

Solutions are not always unique. The game can accept different characters, panel orders or fewer panels when the finished story still satisfies the title. Scene names below follow current walkthrough terminology; localized editions may use different labels.

The full release has 14 chapters. Chapters can be completed in any order. Finish all 14, then in The Ceremony drag the crown from the right page onto the pedestal on the left to unlock the Epilogue. Devilish puzzles, marked with a red star, unlock only after the Ceremony. Sources: Stories in Play, Steam community guide.

Chapter 1 — Life and Death

1-1 Love — Adam starts alone, finds love, and dies happy

1. Adam alone.
2. Adam with Eve.
3. Adam on the grave; Eve beside him.

1-2 Heartbreak — Eve dies heartbroken

1. Love/Wedding — Adam and Eve.
2. Death — Adam on the grave; Eve beside him.
3. Death — Eve on the grave.

1-3 Afterlife — See the ghost of a lover

1. Love/Wedding — Adam and Eve.
2. Death — Adam on the grave; Eve beside him.
3. Ghost — Adam and Eve.

1-4 Miracle — Heartbreak with a happy ending

1. Love/Wedding — Adam and Eve.
2. Death — Adam on the grave; Eve beside him.
3. Revive — Adam.
4. Wedding/Love — Adam and Eve.

Chapter 1 sequences are cross-checked against the published solution list.

Chapter 2 — Broken Hearts

2-1 Recovery — A heartbreak is healed

1. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Death — Lenora on the grave; Edgar beside her.
3. Revive — Lenora.
4. Death — Edgar on the grave; Lenora beside him.
5. Revive — Edgar.
6. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.

An accepted alternative heals the relationship without using Death panels.

2-2 Dismay — Rejected by own spouse

1. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Isobel.

2-3 Unlucky — Everyone rejects Edgar

Establish Edgar’s relationship history, then use successive relationship scenes that make both Lenora and Isobel reject him. Walkthroughs compress this puzzle differently; do not use versions that rename the objective “Edgar Dies” or “Everyone Dies.”

2-4 Grief — Surviving spouses find comfort

1. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Death — Edgar on the grave; Lenora beside him.
3. Wedding/Love — Lenora and Isobel.
4. Death — Lenora on the grave; Isobel beside her.
5. Revive — Edgar.
6. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.

Devilish objective: spouses reject each other.

Chapter 3 — Apparitions

3-1 Revelation — Edgar shocks himself

1. Death — Edgar on the grave.
2. Revive — Edgar.
3. Ghost — Edgar and Edgar.

3-2 Reunion — Heartbroken spouses are reunited

1. Build the Chapter 2 heartbreak setup.
2. Kill one spouse.
3. Kill the other spouse.
4. Revive one spouse.
5. Ghost — the surviving ghost and the revived spouse.

For the alternate “in the afterlife” ending, leave both spouses dead before the Ghost panel.

3-3 Calamity — Heartbreak for everyone

1. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Death — Edgar on the grave; Lenora beside him.
3. Wedding/Love — Lenora and Isobel.
4. Death — Lenora on the grave; Isobel beside her.
5. Revive — Edgar.
6. Wedding/Love — Lenora and Edgar.

Devilish objective: everyone dies sad.

3-4 Aging — Old heartbroken dog dies happy

1. Love — Dog and Edgar.
2. Death — Edgar on the grave; Dog beside him.
3. Time.
4. Revive — Edgar.
5. Repeat panel 1: Love — Dog and Edgar.
6. Death — Dog on the grave.

Chapter 4 — The Cellar

4-1 Poison — Lenora drinks poison

1. Wedding/Love — Lenora with Edgar or Bernard.
2. Death — Lenora beside the grave; the other character on the grave.
3. Poison — Lenora.

4-2 Tragedy — Someone drinks poison twice

1. Complete the 4-1 sequence.
2. Death — the character who was on panel 2’s grave.
3. Poison — the surviving character.

Devilish objective: haunted for murder.

4-3 Haunt — Isobel is haunted by her husband

1. Wedding/Love — Isobel and Edgar.
2. Fight — Isobel and Edgar.
3. Poison — Isobel.
4. Wine — Edgar.
5. Repeat panel 1.

4-4 Envy — Murder of jealousy

1. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Wedding/Love — Edgar and Isobel.
3. Poison — Isobel.
4. Wine — Lenora.

For the “everyone meets their demise” ending, add Poison — Edgar, then Poison — Isobel.

Chapter 5 — Beauty

5-1 Competition — Witch becomes the mirror’s favorite

1. Mirror — Witch.
2. Cauldron — Witch.
3. Forest — Witch and Snowy.
4. Cauldron — Witch.
5. Mirror — Witch.

5-2 Scorn — Curse is lifted

1. Forest — Snowy and Witch.
2. Forest — Snowy and Prince.
3. Kiss — Snowy and Prince.

5-3 Duplicity — A kiss and a curse

1. Cauldron — Witch.
2. Kiss — Witch and Prince.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Repeat panel 2.
5. Forest — Witch and Prince.

Devilish objective: heartbroken frog.

5-4 Deceit — Tiny gets a kiss

1. Mirror — Witch.
2. Forest — Witch and Snowy.
3. Forest — Snowy and Tiny.
4. Kiss — Snowy and Tiny.
5. Repeat panel 1.

Alternate “Prince saves Tiny”: Mirror — Witch; Forest — Snowy and Witch; Kiss — Snowy and Tiny; Forest — Witch and Tiny; Forest — Prince and Snowy; Kiss — Tiny and Prince.

Chapter 6 — The Manor

6-1 Murder — Butler’s rampage

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Ballroom — Butler and Duke.
3. Ballroom — Butler and Duchess.

6-2 Weapon — Duke feels relief

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Gun — Duke.
3. Gun — Butler.
4. Gun — Duke.

6-3 Telltale — Murderer is arrested

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Ballroom — Butler and Duke.
3. Remorse — Butler.
4. Ballroom — Butler and Detective.

6-4 Fingerprints — Detective arrests murderer

1. Gun — Detective.
2. Gun — Butler.
3. Ballroom — Butler and Duke.
4. Gun — Butler.
5. Gun — Detective.
6. Ballroom — Butler and Detective.

This puzzle also has an alternate innocent-arrest objective. Devilish objective: Butler gets shot.

Chapter 7 — Crown Intrigue

7-1 Rivals — Four deaths

1. Cliff — Knight near the edge; Baron beside him.
2. Cliff — Baron near the edge; Knight beside him.
3. Revive — Baron.
4. Revive — Knight.
5. Repeat panel 1.
6. Repeat panel 2.

7-2 Rescue — The queen is rescued

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Baron beside her.
2. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Knight beside her.
3. Wedding — Knight and Queen.

The Wedding panel gives the “and married” ending. For the revenge objective, repeat the first kidnapping setup, then swap the Queen and Baron positions in the final kidnapping panel.

7-3 Usurpers — Everyone sits on the throne

1. Throne — Queen.
2. Cliff — Queen near the edge; Baron beside her.
3. Throne — Knight.
4. Cliff — Knight near the edge; Baron beside him.
5. Throne — Baron.

7-4 Forgiven — Usurper is forgiven

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Dog beside her.
2. Throne — Dog.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Kidnap — Dog in the cage; Queen beside him.
5. Throne — Queen.
6. Repeat panel 4.

7-5 Suitor — The queen marries

1. Disguise — Baron.
2. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Baron beside her.
3. Disguise — Baron.
4. Kidnap — Baron beside Queen.
5. Wedding — Queen and Baron.

Chapter 8 — Secrets

8-1 Red-Handed — Murderer gets arrested

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Witness — Detective.
3. Ballroom — Butler and Duke.
4. Ballroom — Butler and Detective.

8-2 Thief — Butler gets fired

1. Witness — Duke.
2. Gun — Butler.
3. Ballroom — Butler.
4. Gun — Butler.
5. Ballroom — Duke and Butler.

8-3 Revenge — Spouse gets vengeance

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Witness — Duchess.
3. Ballroom — Butler and Duke.
4. Gun — Butler.
5. Gun — Duchess.
6. Ballroom — Butler and Duchess.

Devilish objective: Duke shoots his wife.

8-4 Report — Duchess gets murderer arrested

1. Gun — Butler.
2. Witness — Duchess.
3. Ballroom — Butler.
4. Ballroom — Duchess and Detective.
5. Ballroom — Duchess and Butler.
6. Ballroom — Butler and Detective.

Alternate ending: the duke isn’t home.

Chapter 9 — Justice

9-1 Treason — Usurper dies

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Baron beside her.
2. Throne — Baron.
3. Execute — Baron executes Queen.
4. Kidnap — Baron in the cage; Knight beside him.
5. Throne — Knight.
6. Execute — Knight executes Baron.

Alternate ending: by the hand of the knight.

9-2 Unforgiven — Knight loses his head

1. Death — Queen on the grave; Knight beside her.
2. Throne — Knight.
3. Revive — Queen.
4. Kidnap — Knight in the cage; Queen beside him.
5. Throne — Queen.
6. Execute — Queen executes Knight.

9-3 Stockholm — The execution

Queen executed:

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Baron beside her.
2. Amnesia — Queen.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Wedding — Baron and Queen.
5. Execute — Baron executes Queen.

Baron executed:

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Baron beside her.
2. Amnesia — Baron.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Execute — Queen executes Baron.

9-4 Matriarch — Queen beheads all men

1. Cliff — Baron on the left; Queen beside him.
2. Throne — Knight.
3. Revive — Queen.
4. Wedding — Queen and Knight.
5. Execute — Queen executes Baron.
6. Execute — Queen executes Knight.

Chapter 10 — Genesis

Genesis is Chapter 10 in the full release; the demo’s separate Genesis level is not the same puzzle.

10-1 Temptation — Eve rejects apple

1. Tempt — Adam.
2. Judgment — Adam and Eve.
3. Tempt — Eve.

10-2 Punishment — God is happy at everyone

1. Tempt — Adam.
2. Judgment — Adam and Eve.
3. Tempt — Eve.
4. Revive — Adam.
5. Repeat panel 1.
6. Repeat panel 2.

Devilish objective: Adam dies twice.

10-3 Repentance — Adam watches his love die

1. Love — Adam and Eve.
2. Tempt — Adam.
3. Tempt — Eve.
4. Judgment — Adam.
5. Revive — Adam.
6. Judgment — Adam and Eve.

Alternate ending: because of him.

10-4 Vengeance — Friedrich takes revenge

1. Love — Eve and Friedrich.
2. Tempt — Eve.
3. Judgment — Eve and Friedrich.
4. Gun — Friedrich.
5. Judgment — Friedrich.

Chapter 11 — The King

11-1 Noxious — Cyclic, mutually toxic love affair

1. Love — King and Queen.
2. Fight — King and Queen.
3. Amnesia — King.
4. Amnesia — Queen.
5. Repeat panels 1 and 2.

11-2 Spite — Double execution

1. Affair — Queen in the bush; King and Maid beside her.
2. Execute — Queen executes Maid.
3. Execute — Queen executes King.

Alternate ending, king takes revenge: use the first two panels, then Execute — King executes Queen.

11-3 Purge — Three heads roll

Purge is a separate current Chapter 11 puzzle. Guides that call this entry “Promotion” are misaligned; Promotion is the next puzzle.

11-4 Promotion — Rags to royalty

1. Wedding — King and Queen.
2. Affair — Queen in the bush; King and Maid beside her.
3. Kidnap — Maid in the cage; Queen beside her.
4. Kidnap — King beside Maid.
5. Execute — King executes Queen.
6. Wedding — King and Maid.

11-5 Machiavelli — Baron rules alone

1. Wedding — King and Queen.
2. Cliff — Queen near the edge; Baron beside her.
3. Wedding — King and Maid.
4. Cliff — King near the edge; Baron beside him.
5. Throne — Baron.

Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

Chapter 12 — Monsters

12-1 Werewolf — Bernard drinks poison

The current objective is Bernard drinking poison. Available guide text is incomplete around the opening panels, so do not rely on sequences that omit Bernard’s werewolf state or substitute a generic Poison panel.

12-2 Sematary — Pet returns for revenge

The objective is confirmed, but surviving text extracts do not provide a complete reliable panel sequence. Treat snippets claiming to be definitive with caution.

12-3 Dragon — Queen gets Baron arrested

1. Disguise — Baron.
2. Ballroom — Baron and Queen.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Ballroom — Queen and Detective.
5. Disguise — Detective.
6. Ballroom — Detective and Baron.

12-4 Vampire — Cured of vampirism

1. Professor — Mina.
2. Night — Mina and Dracula.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Professor — Jon.
5. Crypt — Dracula and Jon.
6. Night — Mina.

12-5 Professor — Monster is slain

Werewolf ending:

1. Disguise — Baron.
2. Professor — Baron.
3. Repeat panel 1.
4. Repeat panel 2.
5. Moon — Bernard.
6. Forest — Bernard and Baron.

Dragon ending:

1. Disguise — Baron.
2. Professor — Baron.
3. Professor — Bernard.
4. Forest — Baron and Bernard.

Chapter 13 — Drama

13-1 Narcissus — Mirror praises everyone

1. Mirror — Peachy.
2. Mirror — Hatey.
3. Cliff — Hatey on the left; Peachy beside him.
4. Repeat panel 2.
5. Cliff — Peachy on the left; Hatey beside her.
6. Mirror — Froggy.

13-2 Oedipus — Hatey murders father and marries mother

1. Wedding — Tiny and Peachy.
2. Family — Tiny on the left; Hatey beside him.
3. Wedding — Hatey and Peachy.
4. Cliff — Tiny near the edge; Hatey beside him.
5. Repeat panel 3.
6. Family — Peachy on the left; Hatey beside her.

13-3 Hamlet — Tiny avenges his father

1. Family — Greeny on the left; Hatey beside him.
2. Repeat panel 1, replacing Hatey with Tiny.
3. Fight — Greeny and Hatey.
4. Cliff — Hatey on the left; Greeny beside him.
5. Seance — Tiny and Greeny.
6. Cliff — Tiny on the left; Hatey beside him.

13-4 Salome — Hatey is murdered by his daughter

The objective and alternate “but he was just protecting her” are confirmed, but available text extracts do not expose a reliable complete sequence. A guessed arrangement would be misleading.

13-5 Godot — Tiny and Hatey wait forever

1. Wait — Tiny and Hatey.
2. Wait.
3. Wait.
4. Wait.
5. Wait.
6. Repeat panel 1.

Devilish objective: they all die.

Final Chapter — Novels

Novels 1 — Mad Husband

1. Wedding — Edgar and Lenora.
2. Wedding — Edgar and Isobel.
3. Poison — Isobel.
4. Wine — Lenora.
5. Wedding — Edgar and Isobel.
6. Seance — Edgar and Lenora.
7. Poison — Edgar.
8. Wine — Isobel.

Novels 2 — Loose End

1. Witness — Duke.
2. Ballroom — Duchess and King.
3. Gun — Duke.
4. Witness — King.
5. Ballroom — Duke and Duchess.
6. Witness — Duke.
7. Ballroom — Detective and King.
8. Ballroom — Duke and Detective.

Novels 3 — Vindictive Wife

1. Wedding — Witch and Prince.
2. Mirror — Witch.
3. Cauldron — Witch.
4. Forest — Witch and Snowy.
5. Forest — Snowy and Prince.
6. Kiss — Snowy and Prince.
7. Repeat panel 4.
8. Forest — Witch and Prince.

Novels 4 — Love Revolution

The objective is Knight and Maid murdering the monarchs and having an affair. Current sources confirm the title, but do not provide a complete reliable panel sequence; abbreviated answers that simply kill the King and Queen and marry the Maid omit required relationship and murder-state setup.

Devilish variants

These are optional red-star puzzles unlocked after The Ceremony, not part of the normal chapter progression.

Location	Devilish objective
Chapter 1-2 Heartbreak	Devil makes everyone miserable
Chapter 2-4 Grief	Spouses reject each other
Chapter 3-3 Calamity	Everyone dies sad
Chapter 4-2 Tragedy	Haunted for murder
Chapter 5-3 Duplicity	Heartbroken frog
Chapter 6-4 Fingerprints	Butler gets shot
Chapter 8-3 Revenge	Duke shoots his wife
Chapter 10-2 Punishment	Adam dies twice
Chapter 13-5 Godot	They all die
Final Chapter, Novel 666	The Last Straw — Knight imprisons Queen

The Last Straw — Knight imprisons Queen

1. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Devil beside her.
2. Death — Devil on the grave; Knight beside him.
3. Throne — Knight.
4. Kidnap — Knight.
5. Wedding — Knight and Queen.
6. Execute — Devil.
7. Execute — Queen on the throne; Knight beside her.
8. Kidnap — Queen in the cage; Knight beside her.

What changed in current guides

• The current release contains 14 chapters, counting Final Chapter: Novels—not merely 12 or 13.
• Devilish levels unlock after The Ceremony and are separate from normal progression.
• Multiple valid solutions are intentional; substitutions and shorter panel sequences can work.
• Genesis is Chapter 10 in the full release, distinct from the demo’s Genesis level.
• Older 2024 guides may omit Devilish variants, Secret Stamps, alternate endings and the Final Chapter. The current chapter structure is documented by Stories in Play and the updated Steam guide. Alternate-solution behavior is discussed by esports.gg.

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.