Best Games Like Silent Hill and The Exorcist for Supernatural Psychological Horror

Start with Silent Hill 2 (2024 remake). It is the closest match for guilt-driven psychological horror: the town’s monsters externalize trauma, while fog, puzzles and survival-horror exploration keep you uncertain about what is real. The remake is available on PlayStation 5 and PC.

Choose Alan Wake 2 for a supernatural mystery that bends reality, Visage for a realistic haunted-house nightmare, Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly for explicit spirit encounters, Amnesia: The Bunker for helpless survival and scarce resources, or the Resident Evil 4 remake when you want cult horror with substantially more combat.

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		Silent Hill 2 (PS5)	$29.50	Buy on Amazon
2		Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5	$15.19	Buy on Amazon
3		Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5	$39.88	Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

What counts as psychological supernatural horror?

Psychological horror is built around uncertainty about perception, identity and reality rather than relying only on jump scares. A PlayStation editorial guide describes the genre as placing players in unpredictable situations where the barrier between madness and reality blurs. Supernatural psychological horror adds ghosts, curses, entities, possession or impossible spaces to that uncertainty.

That distinction matters when moving from Silent Hill or The Exorcist. The former is famous for symbolic monsters, guilt, cult imagery and oppressive exploration. The latter points toward possession, ritual and an external evil that must be confronted. No single game reproduces both in equal measure, so the recommendations below separate emotional symbolism, explicit spirits, vulnerability, investigation and action.

#1 Best Overall

Silent Hill 2 (PS5)

• Fully Remade to terrify modern audiences
• KONAMI's intense psychological horror masterpiece SILENT HILL 2 is made exclusively for PlayStation 5
• The main protagonist James Sunderland searches for clues in the namesake town, after receiving a mysterious letter from his wife Mary… who has long been dead
• Experience the eerie monsters and other manifestations of James' consciousness reworked after 20 years
• Made with state-of-the-art technology to play on modern entertainment systems in 4K

$29.50

Buy on Amazon

At a glance: which game should you play?

Silent Hill 2 (2024 remake): the best overall match

Why it fits

Silent Hill 2 is the strongest first recommendation because its horror is inseparable from its protagonist’s guilt and despair. GameSpot describes the game’s central idea as turning personal trauma into literal monsters. The creatures are not merely obstacles; their forms, behavior and presence make an inner crisis visible.

The remake keeps that emotional approach while using the structure of traditional survival horror. Fog limits information, buildings conceal layered routes, and puzzles make the town feel like a psychological maze rather than a backdrop. You are investigating a personal mystery, but every discovery also changes how you interpret the protagonist.

What to expect moment to moment

• Third-person exploration through a hostile, fog-shrouded town and interiors.
• Deliberate combat that supports tension instead of turning the game into an action shooter.
• Environmental clues and puzzles that reward attention to rooms, notes and visual details.
• A sustained focus on grief, guilt, repression and the way trauma can distort reality.

Who should choose it

Pick the remake if your ideal follow-up to Silent Hill is symbolic horror with an emotionally grounded protagonist. It is also the best bridge between that series and possession-themed horror: the supernatural is unmistakable, but its meaning is personal rather than explained through a simple demon-hunting plot.

Alan Wake 2: supernatural mystery that destabilizes reality

Why it fits

Alan Wake 2 follows troubled writer Alan Wake and FBI agent Saga Anderson as they unravel a supernatural mystery. GameSpot emphasizes that the story blurs fiction and reality, making authorship, memory and the act of telling a story part of the threat.

This is a strong choice when you want the unease of an unreliable world but prefer investigation to the dense, maze-like spaces of Silent Hill 2. You move between two protagonists and two connected perspectives, gradually assembling what happened instead of interpreting one person’s guilt through a single continuous journey.

Important difference from Silent Hill

The game is more story-forward and investigative. Its supernatural tension comes from uncovering how reality has been rewritten, while Silent Hill 2 puts symbolic monsters and oppressive navigation at the center. Combat and detective work give you more agency, so it is less about feeling helpless in an unknowable town.

Choose it if

Choose this when your priority is a supernatural thriller with shifting viewpoints, layered clues and a plot that repeatedly asks whether fiction can become physical. It is available on PC, Xbox Series X|S and PlayStation 5.

Visage: the closest haunted-house experience

Why it fits

TechRadar describes Visage as a disturbing psychological-horror game set in a huge house filled with the memories of the dead families who occupied it. That setting supplies the game’s central pressure: ordinary domestic spaces become evidence of earlier suffering, and the house itself feels hostile without needing a constant stream of combat encounters.

Its first-person viewpoint puts doors, corridors and personal objects directly in your field of view. The realism is important. Instead of a mythic town or a battlefield, you are reading a home whose rooms carry traces of people who died there. The resulting dread is intimate and cumulative.

Trade-offs

• Best for: oppressive atmosphere, realistic haunting and slow discovery.
• Less suitable for: players who want frequent weapon use or a clearly explained supernatural mythology.
• Structure: exploration of a large house with puzzles and memory-driven storytelling.

Platform availability is not stated in the cited TechRadar description, so check the current storefront listing for your system before buying.

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly: the clearest spirit-horror pick

Why it fits The Exorcist reference

If your idea of supernatural horror centers on ghosts, ritual and a community marked by tragedy, Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly is the most direct recommendation. PlayStation describes a sinister village haunted by vengeful spirits. The supernatural is visible and active rather than merely implied through symbolism.

Rank #2

Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5

• TERRIFYING ZOMBIES WAITING AROUND EVERY CORNER -- Driven by insatiable hunger, these creatures act on instinct, gnashing their teeth, ripping at flesh, and devouring their victims. The new immersive camera lets you feel their fangs as they sink into your flesh.
• RACCOON CITY, REBUILT IN INTRICATE DETAIL -- The characters, environments, and story have all been rebuilt from the ground up to create a terrifying world that feels both nostalgic and new.
• NEW FOR PLAYSTATION5 – Upgraded features new to the PlayStation5 version of the game include a higher frame rate, 3D audio, added ray tracing, and engaging DualSense support for Haptic Feedback and Adaptive Triggers.

$15.19

Buy on Amazon

The Camera Obscura changes combat

Your primary defense is the Camera Obscura. PlayStation explains that it can repel, capture and seal away spirits. Confrontations therefore require you to face the apparition through the camera instead of simply shooting it from a distance. Waiting for the right moment and managing your position creates vulnerability even when you have a tool that can fight back.

Who should choose it

Choose this game when you want explicit ghost encounters, ritualized danger and a setting where the dead remain central to the mystery. It is less focused on the modern psychological realism of Silent Hill 2, but it offers the strongest match for readers asking specifically for spirits or possession-adjacent dread. The cited PlayStation description does not specify a platform list; verify the edition available in your region.

Amnesia: The Bunker: maximum vulnerability and resource pressure

Premise and pressure

PlayStation places you as a lone French soldier in a desolate First World War bunker with one bullet remaining. The semi-open environment, adaptive threat and hidden nightmare create a different kind of psychological horror: fear comes from not knowing where the creature is, whether your supplies will last and which route remains safe.

How it differs from Silent Hill

The bunker is not a symbolic town built around one character’s guilt. Its horror is immediate and systemic. Light, sound, ammunition and improvised solutions shape each escape attempt. You are encouraged to evade, experiment and retreat rather than clear rooms through combat.

Choose it if

Pick Amnesia: The Bunker if helplessness is more important to you than elaborate mythology. It is especially suited to players who enjoy semi-open exploration, scarce resources and threats that do not behave in a completely scripted way. Platform information is not stated in the cited PlayStation description, so confirm current availability before purchase.

Resident Evil 4 (2023 remake): the action-heavy cult route

Why it belongs on this list

GameSpot describes the remake as a story of cult activity, a mind-controlling parasite, gunplay and melee combat. Those ingredients connect it to the occult and possession-adjacent side of The Exorcist, but the game treats them through action-survival design rather than intimate psychological introspection.

What you gain and lose

• Gain: responsive third-person shooting, close-range melee, enemy variety and a strong forward drive.
• Lose: much of the uncertainty and symbolic quiet that defines Silent Hill 2.
• Best use case: you want supernatural or cult horror but do not want to spend most of the game hiding.

The remake is listed for PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch. Choose it as your first purchase only if combat is a priority; otherwise, begin with Silent Hill 2 and use this as the more kinetic follow-up.

More games to consider

Until Dawn (2024)

The enhanced 2024 version on PlayStation 5 and PC is a cinematic horror adventure in which decisions determine which of eight trapped friends survive. It is built around branching choices and slasher pacing, so it is not a close mechanical match for Silent Hill. Choose it for replayable consequences and ensemble drama.

Luto

PlayStation describes a troubled artist trapped in a shifting home labyrinth. Despair, loss, anxiety, puzzles and unsettling spirits make it a compact option for players who want personal anguish expressed through an impossible house.

Silent Hill: Townfall

This first-person psychological-horror entry is set in the isolated Scottish town of St. Amelia. PlayStation lists fog, monsters and CRTV signals as elements of exploration. Release and storefront status should be verified before purchase because availability can change.

The Sinking City 2

PlayStation describes a supernatural flood, eldritch horrors, ritual clues, journals and masks in a 1920s Arkham-like port city. It is a useful choice for readers who want investigation and cosmic horror, but verify release and platform status before relying on it as an immediately playable recommendation.

Rank #3

Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5

• Solve a Deadly Mystery: What begins as a small-town murder investigation rapidly spirals into a nightmare journey. Uncover the source of the supernatural darkness in this psychological horror story filled with intense suspense and unexpected twists.
• Play As Two Characters: Experience both Alan Wake’s and Saga Anderson’s stories and see events unfold from different perspectives. Switch between Anderson’s life-or-death race to solve the case and Wake’s desperate attempts to rewrite his reality to escape the depths of the Dark Place.
• Explore Two Worlds: Experience two beautiful yet terrifying worlds, each with its own rich cast of characters and deadly threats. Discover majestic landscapes of Cauldron Lake in the Pacific Northwest and the idyllic towns of Bright Falls and Watery. Contrasting sharply, attempt to escape the nightmarish cityscape of the Dark Place.
• Survive With Light: With limited resources, take on powerful supernatural enemies in desperate close-combat situations. It takes more than just a gun to survive: light is the ultimate weapon in the fight against the darkness and will be your refuge when enemies threaten to overwhelm you.
• The physical version of Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition includes the following: ● Alan Wake 2 physical game. ● The Night Springs and Lake House expansions. ● Deluxe Edition cosmetics and items: Nordic Shotgun Skin for Saga, Crimson Windbreaker for Saga, Celebrity Suit for Alan, Parliament Shotgun Skin for Alan, and Lantern Charm for Saga. ● Alan Wake Remastered (Digital Edition - included as a gift with purchase DLC on a voucher).

$39.88

Buy on Amazon

Silent Hill f

PC Gamer lists this 2025 entry from NeoBards as a new direction for the series. It is the natural same-franchise option if you want to stay within Silent Hill while trying a different setting and creative approach.

Mouthwashing

TechRadar highlights surreal and disturbing visuals, a non-linear narrative, difficult themes and a short experience with lasting psychological impact. It is thematically intense, but it is not a supernatural analogue to The Exorcist; choose it for disorientation and emotional severity.

Still Wakes the Deep

TechRadar describes a narrative-led survival-horror game set on a 1970s North Sea oil rig, where a strange entity stalks the corridors. Its atmosphere and isolation are excellent reasons to play it, although the industrial setting and creature focus make it a different flavor of dread from a haunted town or possessed person.

How to choose by the fear you want

For guilt, grief and symbolic monsters

Choose Silent Hill 2 (2024 remake). It gives the clearest connection between a protagonist’s inner life and the creatures occupying the world.

For reality that keeps rewriting itself

Choose Alan Wake 2. Its alternating protagonists and fiction-versus-reality mystery provide the most investigative route into supernatural psychological horror.

For a house that feels contaminated by its history

Choose Visage, especially if first-person exploration and domestic realism matter more to you than combat.

For ghosts, rituals and direct spirit encounters

Choose Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly. The Camera Obscura makes every encounter an act of observation under pressure.

For hiding, improvising and conserving resources

Choose Amnesia: The Bunker. Its lone-soldier setup and adaptive threat create fear through limited options.

For cult horror with constant action

Choose the Resident Evil 4 remake. It is the least psychologically intimate recommendation here, but the strongest for players who want to fight back.

Platform and availability notes

Availability, regional editions, prices and stock can change. The cited listings identify Silent Hill 2 on PlayStation 5 and PC; Alan Wake 2 on PC, Xbox Series X|S and PlayStation 5; and Resident Evil 4 on PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch. The other descriptions do not provide complete platform lists in the available material, so check the current storefront page for your hardware. Release and storefront status for Silent Hill: Townfall and The Sinking City 2 should be confirmed before purchase.

Best first purchase

Buy Silent Hill 2 on PlayStation 5 if you want the most faithful blend of psychological symbolism, supernatural menace, puzzles and survival-horror tension. Follow it with Resident Evil 4 if you want the same broad occult-and-monster territory delivered through faster combat. If ghosts are the non-negotiable requirement, move Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly ahead of both.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

Silent Hill 2 (PS5)

Fully Remade to terrify modern audiences; Made with state-of-the-art technology to play on modern entertainment systems in 4K

$29.50

Bestseller No. 2

Resident Evil 2 - PlayStation 5

$15.19

Bestseller No. 3

Alan Wake 2 Deluxe Edition - PlayStation 5

$39.88

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.