To evaluate a hockey goalie beyond wins and save percentage, compare the shots they faced with the quality of those chances, then check workload, game situations, rebounds and team defense. Start with the basic results, but treat measures such as Goals Saved Above Expected (GSAx) as model-relative evidence—not a definitive ranking of talent or a guarantee of future performance.
What wins, save percentage and goals-against average tell you
A win records the game outcome; it does not isolate the goalie’s contribution from the team’s scoring and defense. Save percentage is the fraction of shots on goal stopped. Goals-against average (GAA) reports goals allowed relative to playing time. Both describe results, but neither tells you how dangerous the shots were.
A goalie who faces mostly low-danger shots and a goalie who faces repeated close-range chances can finish with the same save percentage while having faced very different workloads. Use conventional stats to establish the outcome and scale, not as a complete measure of individual performance.
How shot-quality-adjusted goalie metrics work
Expected goals against and expected save percentage
MoneyPuck defines expected goals against as the sum of expected-goal values for the unblocked shot attempts a goalie faces. Its expected save percentage estimates the save percentage an average NHL goalie would have produced against that shot quality. These are model estimates, so their meaning depends on the provider’s model and definitions. MoneyPuck’s glossary explains its goalie metrics.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
#1 Best Overall
- REFLEX BUILDER: The Champro Reaction Ball is designed to bounce randomly, so athletes can enhance their hand-eye coordination and improve reaction time.
- VERSATILE: Train with the Reaction Ball to prepare for any sport. Athletes honing their skills to perform in baseball, softball, football, soccer, or hockey games can decrease their reaction time, improve alertness, and enhance agility.
- SOLO OR PARTNER TRAINING: Train solo by throwing the reaction ball against a wall or work with a partner to create drills with extreme and unexpected flight paths.
- DURABILITY: The ball is made of highly durable, long-lasting rubber
- FUN: Not only is this item a great way to train for all sports, but it’s also an entertaining way to play with your dog, kids, or friends.
Goals Saved Above Expected
In MoneyPuck’s definition, GSAx equals expected goals against minus actual goals conceded. A positive result means the goalie allowed fewer goals than the model expected; a negative result means more. For example, if a model assigns 4.0 expected goals against and the goalie concedes 3, the hypothetical GSAx is +1.0. That example illustrates the arithmetic, not a real player’s result.
Save Percentage Above Expected is actual save percentage minus expected save percentage. It expresses the difference in percentage-point terms rather than goals. Check the provider’s definition before comparing figures: metrics with similar names may use different inputs or exclusions.
Rank #2
- Innovative, slick pad wax, made with quality soy wax.
NHL EDGE Saves Above Projected
NHL EDGE describes Saves Above Projected as a comparison between shots on goal and the summed projected goal rate of inferred attempts. Its calculation excludes specified categories, including shots from beyond 60 feet, shots from beyond the goal line and shots against an empty net. It is related to GSAx in purpose, but it is not necessarily the same calculation. Name the provider and use one provider consistently when comparing goalies. NHL.com’s explanation of the metric provides its definition.
A practical sequence for evaluating a goalie
- Set the comparison boundaries. Record the league, season, regular-season or playoff sample, strength state, number of appearances and data provider or model. Avoid comparing values across different model versions or periods without confirming that their definitions match.
- Establish workload and basic outcomes. Note games or minutes played, shots faced, goals against, save percentage and GAA. These show how much work the goalie did and what happened, but do not assign full credit for the result.
- Compare results with shot quality. Review expected goals against, expected save percentage, GSAx or Saves Above Projected, depending on the provider. Keep the provider attached to the statistic: MoneyPuck GSAx and NHL EDGE Saves Above Projected are not interchangeable labels for a single universal formula.
- Break out situations. Look at 5-on-5 and high-danger results instead of relying only on a season aggregate. NHL.com’s 2026 goalie analysis uses both high-danger save measures and 5-on-5 save percentage as evaluation examples. The feature describes those measures in context; its player-specific season figures are not evergreen benchmarks.
- Inspect second chances and defensive context. When available, compare observed rebounds and freezes with expected rates. A rebound count can reflect the goalie’s control, but also whether defenders clear the crease and loose pucks. MoneyPuck specifically cautions against attributing every rebound outcome to the goalie alone. Its methodology discussion explains that context.
- Describe what the team allowed without calling it goalie skill. Tracking and zone information can help explain the defensive environment around a goalie. NHL EDGE presents tracking information and danger-zone context, but team-level zone time is not itself a goalie skill statistic. NHL EDGE provides the league’s public tracking presentation.
- State how much confidence the sample supports. Treat a small sample as provisional rather than as settled evidence of ability. Hockey performance measurement is a difficult summarization and credit-assignment problem, as discussed in this peer-reviewed review of hockey analytics. Adjusted metrics still depend on model construction and team context.
How to compare two goalies fairly
Use the same provider, definitions and time period for both goalies. A compact comparison should cover:
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Rank #3
- NOTE: Please select either the small or large size according to the dimensions of the hockey goal to avoid sizing errors.
- 72" GOALIE SHOOTING TARGET:Upgraded 7-hole layout, highly replicating the scoring area in a match. Practice shooting by hitting the corners and beating the goalkeeper to effectively improve shooting accuracy and technique.
- 600D THICKENED TARGET NET : This hockey shooting tarp is made of thickened 600D polyester fabric with reinforced stitching, providing stronger wear resistance and water repellency. It can withstand the most difficult shots while maintaining its shape and withstanding various environmental tests.
- REALISTIC GAME SCENARIOS: High-contrast, realistic goalkeeper patterns recreate real game scenarios. Through intensive training focused on locking onto target areas, players can learn to break through the goalkeeper's defence in real matches.
- EASY TO INSTALL: Reinforced straps fit snugly on any standard 72" X 48" Hockey Goal and can be installed in less than a minute, completely solving the problem of target net displacement during training. The foldable structure is convenient for transportation and storage.
- Workload: appearances or minutes and shots faced.
- Adjusted results: a shot-quality measure such as GSAx, calculated by the same model for both.
- Situational splits: 5-on-5 and high-danger performance, with the sample shown.
- Second chances and team defense: rebound or freeze measures where available, alongside relevant defensive context.
- Uncertainty: the size of each sample and any model differences that limit the comparison.
A season total can hide a weak or strong split, while a narrow split can overstate small-sample variation. Avoid ranking goalies from one small slice or mixing providers’ figures as if they were calculated alike.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What these numbers can—and cannot—say about a hot streak
A positive past GSAx means the goalie conceded fewer goals than one model expected over that sample. It does not, by itself, show that the goalie will keep outperforming expectations or that recent success will continue at the same rate.
Rank #4
- 54" GOALIE SHOOTING TARGET: Practice your shooting by hitting the corners and beating the goaltender with this easy attach practice target
- EASY SET UP: Adjustable self-stick straps wrap around the goal posts for easy and quick installation on any standard 54" x 44" goal
- DURABLE FLEX FABRIC: The rugged nylon fabric is built tough to handle even the hardest slap shots and the waterproof construction ensures that this target can stand up to the elements
- IMPROVE YOUR SKILLS: This dynamic 54" goalie shooting target is perfect for practicing shot accuracy and location to help you become an elite goal scorer!
- OFFICIAL STREET HOCKEY BALL: Designed for use with official 2 5/8" street hockey ball only
A 2021 study by Likang Ding, Ivor Cribben, Armann Ingolfsson and Monica Tran examined 48,431 shots faced by 93 goaltenders in the 2008–2016 NHL playoffs. The authors reported no evidence for a hot-hand effect across the recent-performance windows they tested. That finding is specific to that population, period and analysis; it does not establish that momentum is impossible in every league or under every definition. Read the study.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Two (2) Regulation Ice Hockey Training Pucks
- Great Training Tool for Goalies
- Manufactured by Inglasco, Official Puck Supplier to the NHL
- Official Size (3" Diameter) & Weight (6 oz.)
- Color: White
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
