Sea of Thieves has no official ranking of its monsters by how frightening they are. For sudden, ship-level dread, the Kraken is the strongest pick. The Megalodon is a close second for players who find giant sharks more unsettling. That verdict is an editorial judgment based on how Rare describes the two creatures, not a statement from the developer.
Why there is no official answer
Rare’s official Sea of Thieves material describes each session as unpredictable and lists the Megalodon and the Kraken among the threats crews meet at sea. It does not rank them by how scary they are. PlayStation’s game page takes the same approach. It lists Phantoms, Ocean Crawlers, Megalodons and the Kraken among the game’s foes, and it does not compare them. Any “scariest” pick is therefore a judgment about the style of threat each creature presents. The quoted wording below is paraphrased from Rare’s official copy as published, so check Rare’s live pages for exact phrasing.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Sea of Thieves The Board Game: Voyage of Legends | $44.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Sea of Thieves: Standard Edition – Xbox One | $38.87 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Sea of Thieves Xbox One (Renewed) | $30.14 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
![Sea of Thieves: Standard Edition – Xbox One [Digital Code]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41RiuntPiNL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Sea of Thieves: Standard Edition – Xbox One [Digital Code] | $35.19 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
Sea of Thieves - Xbox One/PC - Full Game - Key Card | $57.90 | Buy on Amazon |
The Kraken: dread that hits the whole ship
The Kraken’s signature is its tentacles, and Rare’s official copy emphasises them. The threat is aimed at the vessel rather than at one pirate in the water. The whole crew is pulled into a fight that affects everyone aboard. Rare also warns that an unprepared crew can end up on the Ferry of the Damned, the game’s lore destination for a lost crew. That warning makes the encounter feel like a real way to lose a voyage, not just a fight to be survived.
The Kraken also appears and attacks ships in Safer Seas, according to Rare’s Safer Seas FAQ. This matters because it means the creature is not limited to one mode of play.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →#1 Best Overall
- Welcome, pirates! Have you ever dreamed of being out on the open waves in search of treasure and adventure?
- Well then, the Sea of Thieves is calling!
- Inspired by the hit video game, Sea of Thieves: Voyage of Legends is a competitive seafaring game of piracy for 2-4 players.
- Explore the high seas with your friends in voyages packed with danger and excitement, but don't forget - only one of you can be crowned a Pirate Legend...
- You'll build a fearsome reputation as you compete for that title, battling sea monsters and pilfering plunder as you go.
The Megalodon: a single predator in open water
Rare’s copy evokes the Megalodon’s teeth, and its Safer Seas FAQ states that Megalodons still roam and attack ships in that mode. The Megalodon is a more visible, single predator. Its threat is easy to picture: a giant shark closing in on the ship. Rare places it under the same Ferry of the Damned warning as the Kraken. For players whose fear is driven by sharks, this is the stronger case, and it is the one most players will recognise immediately.
The two creatures side by side
| Creature | Type of threat | What official sources say | Fear rating in official sources | Strength of the “scariest” case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kraken | Ship-wide: tentacles attack the vessel and the whole crew | Rare emphasises the tentacles; the Kraken attacks ships in Safer Seas; an unprepared crew can end up on the Ferry of the Damned | Not stated | Strongest for sudden, crew-wide dread (editorial judgment) |
| Megalodon | Single giant predator: teeth and attacks on ships in open water | Rare evokes the teeth; Megalodons still roam and attack ships in Safer Seas; same Ferry of the Damned warning | Not stated | Strong for readers whose fear is shark-driven (editorial judgment) |
The two are compared on the kind of threat and the open-sea setting, not on any measured fear response. Neither Rare’s official pages nor PlayStation’s game page gives a comparable fear rating for either creature.
Rank #2
- A shared-world adventure game by acclaimed UK developer Rare Ltd. Xbox Live Gold required to play (sold separately)
- Live the essential pirate life in a world rich with Rare’s irreverent charm. Sail and fight together, hunt treasure and create your own legends
- A fantastical world of unspoiled islands, mythical monsters and mouth-watering loot. Total freedom to decide how you approach the world and its players
- Xbox One Console exclusive
- Battery: no battery used;Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) Content Description: Crude humor, use of alcohol, violence
Safer Seas does not remove either creature
Rare’s Safer Seas FAQ says both the Megalodon and the Kraken remain in that mode and attack ships there. Choosing Safer Seas therefore does not change which of the two you may meet. The same FAQ says the Shrouded Ghost has the same rarity in Safer Seas and High Seas, so the mode choice does not change how often that variant appears.
Both modes are offered on PlayStation’s game page, which also lists a PS5 release. Pricing and availability change by region and date, so check the storefront in your region before buying.
Quick Recap
Rank #4
- Sea of Thieves offers the essential pirate experience, from sailing and fighting to exploring and looting – everything you need to live the pirate life and become a legend in your own right.
- Whether you’re voyaging as a group or sailing solo, you’re bound to encounter other crews in this shared-world adventure – but will they be friends or foes, and how will you respond?
Rank #3
- A shared-world adventure game by acclaimed UK developer Rare Ltd. Xbox Live Gold required to play (sold separately)
- Live the essential pirate life in a world rich with Rare's irreverent charm. Sail and fight together, hunt treasure and create your own legends!
- A fantastical world of unspoiled islands, mythical monsters and mouth-watering loot
- Total freedom to decide how you approach the world and its players
- Available on the Xbox One family of devices and Windows 10 PCs. Supports Xbox Play Anywhere and cross-platform play** (**Play on one device at a time. PC hardware requirements may vary for games on Windows 10).The Hungering Deep, the first major Sea of Thieves content update landing May 2018, brings with it an exciting new threat to the Sea of Thieves world. Work together with other crews on a completely new adventure with gameplay enhancements and unique rewards.The May kick-off of the Sea of Thieves weekly events programme also introduces fun new ways to play with weekly events and rewards.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
