In FIFA 15’s standard player overall ratings, Jérôme Boateng, Sergio Ramos and Thiago Silva share the top centre-back rating at 87. If you mean the best Ultimate Team card, Sergio Ramos is the highest-rated centre-back on the FIFPlay FIFA 15 list at 94. The two answers come from different rating systems, so the right one depends on what you are comparing.
Standard overall ratings: a three-way tie at 87
FIFA Index’s FIFA 15 ranking of “top-rated center-backs” puts Boateng, Ramos and Thiago Silva at 87 overall, with no single leader. Mats Hummels and Vincent Kompany follow at 86. This is the ordinary player overall that the game uses for standard player ratings, so it is the closest match to the question if you are asking about how players rate in general rather than about a specific collectible card. (FIFA Index FIFA 15 centre-back rankings)
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
FIFA 15 - PlayStation 4 | $38.53 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
FIFA 15 (PS4) | $76.35 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
FIFA 15 Ultimate Team Edition (PS4) | $12.88 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
FIFA 16 - Standard Edition - PlayStation 4 | $23.50 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
FIFA 15 PS4 | $12.66 | Buy on Amazon |
A Premier League squad guide from FIFAUTEAM is consistent with that scale. It lists Kompany at 86 among the league’s highest-rated centre-backs, which supports the reading that 86 to 87 was the ceiling for standard CB overalls in the league context. (FIFAUTEAM FIFA 15 Premier League squad guide)
Ultimate Team cards: Ramos at 94
FIFPlay’s FIFA 15 centre-back page lists Sergio Ramos at 94, the highest card rating on that page. It also shows Franz Beckenbauer and Thiago Silva at 93, then several Legends at 92 and 89. This list includes special cards and Legends, so it is not a count of standard player overalls. (FIFPlay FIFA 15 CB player list)
#1 Best Overall
- FIFA 15 brings soccer to life in stunning detail so fans can experience the emotion of the sport like never before.
Which answer applies to your question
| Rating context | Highest centre-back | Rating | Source and scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard player overall (Career Mode and base ratings) | Jérôme Boateng, Sergio Ramos and Thiago Silva (tied) | 87 | FIFA Index FIFA 15 centre-back ranking; the page does not state a publication date for these entries |
| Ultimate Team card rating (special cards and Legends included) | Sergio Ramos | 94 | FIFPlay FIFA 15 CB list; the page does not state a publication date for these entries |
Because the two lists measure different things, a card rated 94 is not a better standard player than an 87 overall in the sense the rankings use. Check which context your question means before comparing numbers.
Both sources are fan databases rather than EA publications, and the rating snapshots they show are not dated, so they reflect the game as those sites recorded it. Treat the figures as the best-documented listings available rather than official EA data.
Rank #2
- Models the emotions of all 22 players on the pitch for contextual in-game reactions
- Teams have contextual awareness of the game and dynamically adjust their tactics
- Authentic player visuals, rendering lighting system, and realistic environmental effects
- More responsiveness and control, giving personality to recognised world players
- Improved mechanics for man-to-man battles; correct contacts; and set piece control
Quick guide to the terms
- CB means centre-back, the central defender position.
- Overall is the single rating that represents a player’s general strength in the game’s standard player data.
- Card rating is the rating on an Ultimate Team card, which can be higher than a player’s base overall because special cards and Legends carry different ratings.
FIFA 15 was released in 2014, and the rating figures above describe that edition only.
For most readers, the answer that matches the question “highest rated” is the standard overall rating of 87, shared by three defenders. If you are building an Ultimate Team squad or comparing cards, the Ramos 94 card is the answer that applies.
Quick Recap
Best Value
Rank #4
- Includes the standard edition of FIFA 16 for PlayStation 4
- Supports single-player, local multiplayer, and online multiplayer
- Interception Intelligence - Rewritten for FIFA 16, Interception Intelligence can be adjusted in Custom Tactics so you can control how aggressive your teammates are on the ball
- No Touch Dribbling - Lionel Messi was motion captured to create an innovative dribble control system that gives players the freedom to decide not just how, but when to touch the ball
- Women's National Teams - For the first time ever in an EA SPORTS FIFA franchise title, compete with 12 top-ranked Women's National Teams
Rank #3
- Ultimate Team Edition includes Ultimate Team 40 Gold Packs, celebrations, kits, and more
- Models the emotions of all 22 players on the pitch for contextual in-game reactions
- Teams have contextual awareness of the game and dynamically adjust their tactics
- Authentic player visuals, environmental effects, and more responsiveness and control
- Improved mechanics for man-to-man battles; correct contacts; and set piece control
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
