The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Best overall: the Bully Tools 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel is the strongest general-purpose pick among the reviewed options. Bob Vila named it best overall after testing ten shovels in its guide updated March 4, 2025, and Popular Mechanics also selected it for that category in September 2024. But there is no single best shovel for every job: a spade is better suited to transplanting, a square-point shovel to scooping, and a trench shovel to digging narrow channels.
This is a U.S.-oriented, task-based ranking, not a claim that these tools have been independently tested side by side here. Match the blade and handle to the work you actually do.
What is the best shovel for digging?
For general digging, start with a round-point shovel. Its pointed blade is shaped to cut into soil, and its upper edge lets you apply downward pressure with a foot. Among the models in this ranking, the Bully Tools 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel is the best-supported all-around choice: Bob Vila named it best overall in a guide updated March 4, 2025, and Popular Mechanics did the same in its September 23, 2024 roundup.
That recommendation comes with a trade-off. Bob Vila described the shovel as heavy and premium-priced; its test guide reported a weight of 5.6 lb and rated ease of use 4/5, comfort 4/5, performance 4.3/5, and value 4.7/5. Those are Bob Vila’s reported test results, not measurements made for this article. Its guide also cautioned against using excessive prying force against rocks or thick roots.
#1 Best Overall
- STEVEN RHODES ART AND EASY-TO-LEARN GAMEPLAY: Based on the artwork of Steven Rhodes, an illustrator best known for his offbeat reimagining of children’s activity books from the ’70s and ’80s, Let’s Dig for Treasure immerses you in hilariously dark retro worlds. It features fast-paced, easy-to-learn gameplay with very little setup time, while offering hidden depth to satisfy hardcore gamers.
- PUSH YOUR LUCK!: It’s a fresh take on the push-your-luck mechanic as you shuffle up the cards, put them into three stacks, and “dig” for treasure! There are tons of fun treasures and combos, but be sure to stop digging and score your points before you hit too many Worms or even worse… the Evil Skeleton! Play continues until one stack is depleted and then it’s time to add up the scores; whomever has the most treasure wins the game!
- KEY FEATURES: The game is from Dynomite Games, an old-school sub-brand of Cryptozoic Entertainment, and features art inspired by popular illustrator Steven Rhodes. It is for 2-5 players (ages 12+) and has an estimated playtime of 10-20 minutes per game.
- INSIDE THE BOX: 120 Cards, 1 Rulebook.
- ABOUT CRYPTOZOIC ENTERTAINMENT: Since 2010, Cryptozoic Entertainment has been dedicated to the concept of "Fans First," striving to develop the most creative and sought-after products for pop culture enthusiasts worldwide. As an entertainment company with a diverse portfolio of licensed and original IPs, its catalog covers a broad spectrum of tabletop games and collectibles. The passionate team at Cryptozoic aims to inspire gamers and collectors and bring fans together.
Dig shovel tier list: picks by task
The ranking below follows the task categories in Popular Mechanics’ September 23, 2024 guide. Its selections are useful for matching shovel shape to the work, but current specifications, availability, and prices for every alternative have not been established here.
| Tier / task | Pick | Why it fits | What to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top all-around | Bully Tools 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel | Round point for general soil cutting and digging; selected as best overall by Bob Vila (2025) and Popular Mechanics (2024). | Bob Vila reported 5.6 lb in its test and called it heavy and premium-priced. Manufacturer-listed weights vary by handle version. |
| Value digging | Kobalt Fiberglass Handle Digging Shovel | Popular Mechanics’ value pick for digging. | Current specifications, price, and stock are not stated in the reviewed source material. |
| Scooping | Truper Tru-Pro 48-Inch Square Point Shovel | Square-point blade selected for scooping. | Current specifications, price, and stock are not stated in the reviewed source material. |
| Transplanting | Fiskars Steel Garden Spade Shovel | Spade selected for transplanting. | Popular Mechanics names the model; Fiskars’ 2026 catalogue provides broader product-category context but does not specifically verify this U.S. model. |
| Trenching | Bully Tools 14-Gauge Trench Shovel | Trench-specific form selected for digging trenches. | Current specifications, price, and stock are not stated in the reviewed source material. |
Category selections in the table are Popular Mechanics’ editorial recommendations, not a shared measured scorecard across all five tools. The scores and test weight listed for the Bully 12-gauge model come separately from Bob Vila’s 2025 guide.
Rank #2
- 8-Bit, Evolved: With Shovel Knight, handcrafted pixel art meets the tech of today: detailed animation, multilayered parallax backgrounds, and evolved game design
- Perfect Platforming: Flip enemies! Leap over gaps! Duel with foes! Dig up treasure! Find secrets! Upgrade! Shovel Knight is simple to learn and play, but challenge lies everywhere.
- Sweeping Story: Heroes, villains, and tons of lovable characters are stuffed with personality, and showcase a light touch to narrative with humor and levity.
- Legendary Soundtrack: A sweeping score composed by legends of the industry Jake Kaufman and Manami Matsumae, best known for scoring the original Mega Man.
- More on the Way!: Every copy of Shovel Knight will be updated for FREE with new content. 3 New full Campaigns starring familiar foes, Challenge Mode, Battle Mode, Body Swap Mode.
Best overall: Bully Tools 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel
Bully Tools lists this shovel with a 12-gauge U.S.-made steel head, fiberglass handle, reinforced neck and rivets, closed back, welded I-beam construction at the ferrule, and a footstep. The manufacturer offers a 46-inch D-grip version weighing 5 lb and a 60-inch long-handle version weighing 5.5 lb. These are manufacturer specifications; Bob Vila’s separately reported test weight was 5.6 lb.
The manufacturer describes it for tough soil, rocks, roots, trenching, planting, and ground preparation, and lists a limited lifetime warranty covering defects in material and workmanship. These are product and warranty claims from Bully Tools, not independent durability findings. The product page displayed $59.99 when accessed on October 8, 2026; online prices and stock can change.
Crashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minutePC Slower Than It Used to Be?
A free scan shows the junk files, broken settings and background clutter dragging Windows down - then fixes them in one click.Free scan · Windows 10 & 11Rank #3
- Toys that Teach: This deluxe excavation kit has everything needed to uncover 8 gems, fossils and other fun treasures. It’s a great hands-on science lesson for young scientists!
- Individual or Group Activity: MindWare Dig It Up! dragon egg includes one big egg and 7 dragon egg toys inside, making it fun for one child or a great playdate activity for kids to enjoy together!
- Dig it Up Discoveries: Soak the clay forms in water, then chisel away to uncover each treasure inside! Discover gems, fossils, dinosaurs and a skeleton to assemble.
- Easy Clean Up: Dig It Up! fans will love the authenticity of the sturdy pieces in this kit, and caregivers will love setting down the impressive excavation mat for easy clean-up when the exploration is done.
- Includes 1 flat dig with 8” dinosaur model, 1 large 4” egg with 3 dinosaurs, 2 Jurassic rocks with fossils, 2 prehistoric crystal digs with gems, 1 excavation mat, 1 explorer vest, 1 explorer hat, 3 chisels, 1 hammer, 1 brush, 1 sponge, 1 magnifying glass, 8 collector fact cards and instructions (for ages 4 and up).
Choose the 12-gauge model if you want the reinforced, heavier-duty option and do not mind the weight. For repeated digging over several hours, the weight Bob Vila noted is a practical consideration, especially if you prefer a lighter tool.
Which shovel is best for hard or rocky soil?
A round-point shovel is the most relevant shape in this ranking for cutting into soil, and Bully Tools describes its 12-gauge model as intended for tough soil, rocks, and roots. Bob Vila’s guide also warns that excessive prying against rocks or thick roots can be a problem. The available evidence does not establish a universally best shovel for every kind of hard or rocky ground, so treat the 12-gauge pick as a general-purpose candidate rather than a guarantee that it will handle any obstruction.
Rank #4
- FUN FOR ADULTS AND FAMILIES: Digsaw is a party game for the whole family. 1 to 6 players, where each game takes only 20 to 30 minutes.
- UNIQUE PLAY EXPERIENCE: Digsaw is a roll-and-cut game unlike any other, where players use the included scissors to dig for hidden treasure.
- SIMPLE WITH STRATEGY: Digsaw is a game that's accessible, rewarding, and easy to learn with strategic depht. Roll the dice, wield your scissors precisely, and carefully plan your cuts to maximize your archaeological finds.
- FIVE DIFFICULTY LEVELS: With five distinct difficulty levels, Digsaw offers a customizable experience tailored to players of all skill levels.
- SIMULTANEOUS PLAY: Each player makes their gameplay decisions at the same time, making for an engaging experience that includes every player in each fun-filled moment.
When to choose a different shovel
For scooping: a square-point shovel
A square-point blade is the better match when the task is moving or scooping loose material rather than piercing into undisturbed ground. Popular Mechanics selected the Truper Tru-Pro 48-Inch Square Point Shovel for scooping. Its roundup does not establish current price, stock, or a full specification set for the model.
For transplanting: a spade
A spade is the task-specific choice when you need to work around plants. Popular Mechanics named the Fiskars Steel Garden Spade Shovel best for transplanting. Fiskars’ 2026 gardening catalogue distinguishes spade and shovel models by task, but it is not a specific verification of the exact U.S. model named in the roundup.
Best Value
- Nice Size for Beach Play: Designed with an ideal size of 11.1” x 4.25” x 1.37”, this beach shovel is nice for kids and adults to dig, scoop, and build sand structures. Great for beach trips, sandboxes, and outdoor fun.
- Sturdy & Rust-Resistant Material: Made of high-quality aluminum alloy, this sand shovel is sturdy, lightweight, and resistant to rust and corrosion. Built to withstand repeated use at the beach, park, or backyard.
- Ergonomic & Comfortable Grip: Featuring an ergonomic handle for a comfortable hold, this beach toy reduces hand fatigue during extended play. The hook design allows easy hanging and storage after use.
- Smooth Edge for Easy Scooping: The smooth, rounded edge allows effortless digging and scooping of sand without hurting hands. Nice for building sandcastles, digging holes, or collecting shells.
- Great Gift for Beach Lovers & Kids : A fun and practical addition to any beach toy set. Ideal as a summer gift, birthday present, or vacation essential for kids, families, and beach enthusiasts. Backed by responsive customer service for a worry-free purchase.
For narrow trenches: a trench shovel
For digging trenches, Popular Mechanics selected Bully Tools’ 14-Gauge Trench Shovel. A trench tool is a more task-focused option than using a general-purpose round-point shovel for every cut. Current model specifications and retail availability are not established here.
Is the Bully Tools 14-Gauge round-point shovel a lighter alternative?
It may be, depending on configuration, but “14-gauge” does not mean a thicker head than “12-gauge.” Bully Tools says its 12-gauge head is thicker. The manufacturer lists the 14-gauge round-point shovel at 4.5–5.5 lb across versions, with fiberglass or hardwood handles, D-grip or long-handle options, and open- or closed-back variants. Listed lengths include 46- and 60-inch versions, while some product dimensions show 58 inches. Check the exact configuration before comparing weight or length.
Bully Tools lists a limited lifetime warranty for defects in material and workmanship for this model as well. Its “up to 30% more durable” comparison is manufacturer marketing, not an independent test result. The product page also reports that The Spruce featured the model as “Best Shovel” in a 2024 gardening-tools article; that award reference is reported by the manufacturer.
How to choose the right shovel for your yard
- Start with the material and motion. Choose a round point to cut into soil, a square point to scoop, a spade for transplanting, or a trench shovel for trenching.
- Compare the whole tool, not only the blade gauge. Handle material, grip style, length, weight, back design, and the head-to-handle joint affect whether a shovel suits your work.
- Factor in time and comfort. A heavier shovel may be acceptable for occasional jobs but tiring during prolonged digging. Bob Vila’s ratings cover ease, comfort, performance, and value for its selected overall pick; they are not ratings for every shovel in the table.
- Confirm the exact configuration before buying. Bully’s 12- and 14-gauge round-point models have multiple handle and grip versions, and the listed weights differ by configuration. Retail price and stock are changeable.
Sources and scope
The ranking draws on Bob Vila’s guide updated March 4, 2025, Popular Mechanics’ roundup dated September 23, 2024, and Bully Tools’ manufacturer product pages accessed October 8, 2026. It is U.S.-oriented. The named selections are editorial recommendations from those publications; this article does not claim first-hand testing, market-wide durability data, or current retail availability for every alternative.
Quick Recap
- Bob Vila: Best Shovels
- Popular Mechanics: Best Shovels
- Bully Tools: 12-Gauge Round Point Shovel
- Bully Tools: 14-Gauge Round Point Shovel
- Fiskars: Gardening Tools catalogue
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
