Madden NFL 24 received mixed reviews from critics, while the Metacritic user-rating snapshot available on October 8, 2026, was sharply negative. Reviewers who praised the game highlighted improved on-field play and additions to select modes; common criticisms included slow menus and familiar problems beyond the core gameplay. Platform generation matters: several promoted features were tied to PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC.
What were the Madden NFL 24 review scores?
Metacritic listed Madden NFL 24 with a 65 Metascore from 22 critic reviews and a 1.8 user score from 312 user ratings when accessed on October 8, 2026. The game was released on August 18, 2023. These are Metacritic snapshots, not fixed scores or a representative poll of all players. Metacritic’s Madden NFL 24 reviews page classified critic reception as “Mixed or Average” and user reception as “Overwhelming Dislike.”
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
MADDEN NFL 24 Standard PS5 | VideoGame | English | $15.00 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Madden NFL 24 - Xbox Series X and Xbox One | $17.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Madden NFL 24 - For PlayStation 5 | $16.14 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
![Madden NFL 24 Standard - Steam PC [Online Game Code]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51I1h2Q4KnL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Madden NFL 24 Standard - Steam PC [Online Game Code] | $69.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
Madden NFL 25 (PS4) Brand New Sealed , PS 4 | $69.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| Metacritic category | Share and count shown October 8, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Critics: positive | 32% (7 reviews) |
| Critics: mixed | 59% (13 reviews) |
| Critics: negative | 9% (2 reviews) |
| Users: positive | 9% (29 ratings) |
| Users: mixed | 10% (30 ratings) |
| Users: negative | 81% (253 ratings) |
The critic distribution was mostly mixed, while the user breakdown skewed strongly negative. Those percentages describe the ratings displayed on that site at the access date; they do not establish how every player felt.
What did reviewers like about Madden NFL 24?
Positive review excerpts focused on improvements to the on-field experience. Some critics also welcomed Superstar Showdown and changes to Franchise and Superstar. The favorable case, then, was not that every part of the package had been rebuilt, but that gameplay and particular modes offered reasons to play for fans who value those areas.
#1 Best Overall
- American football simulation game brings all the intensity and realism of NFL players, drafts, and strategies to your console - Game modes include Superstar: The League, Superstar: Showdown, Franchise, Madden Ultimate Team, and Cross-play for endless variation.
- Anatomically accurate player skeletons are more responsive, achieving true-to-life player motion during gameplay - Field SENSE animation technology provides greater control, realism, and immersive Ness when performing complex maneuvers.
- AI enhanced movement makes it easier for your team to execute your gameplan with ball carrier pathfinding and QB and DB awareness.
- Skill-based Passing 2.0 has improved accuracy, DB behavior, and catching for more intuitive throwing and defensive actions.
- Hit Everything 2.0 gives your teammates greater situational awareness, allowing them to push the pile and gain ground to attack the football more effectively.
What were the main criticisms?
Reviewers also described slow menus, persistent series problems, predictable modes, and imperfect AI. Some felt the annual additions did not move the game far enough forward. These are reported review assessments, not claims of independent testing here, and they help explain why improved gameplay did not translate into broad critical enthusiasm.
Which platforms get the advertised features?
EA’s June 7, 2023 launch announcement described SAPIEN character-model technology and FieldSENSE gameplay updates. It said Superstar Mode and mini-games returned on PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC, and described cross-play for head-to-head and certain online multiplayer modes on those platforms. These were publisher descriptions at launch, not independent judgments of feature quality. EA’s announcement is useful for the original platform scope.
Rank #2
- SAPIEN TECHNOLOGY – A leap forward in character technology introduces new anatomically accurate NFL player skeletons that are more responsive and true-to-life player motion.
- INCREASED CONTROL AND REALISM – The newest iteration of FieldSENSE provides an enhanced gameplay foundation giving you greater control and delivering realism to all the ways you play.
- YOUR STARDOM. YOUR STORY. – Achieve greatness in your NFL career with game-changing control. Select your position, body type and customize your Superstar and build your legacy.
- AI ENHANCEMENTS – Smarter AI enables smoother and more realistic player action and reaction to the plays you call, providing more confidence your AI teammates will execute your gameplan the way you intend.
- DUAL ENTITLEMENT - Madden NFL 24 includes Dual Entitlement, which lets you upgrade your copy of Madden NFL 24 from Xbox One to Xbox Series X|S. *Conditions apply.
NFL.com’s pre-release feature report also covered gameplay and AI changes, Franchise tools, Superstar, and cross-play. It reported that cross-play would not be available in Franchise at launch. That is a launch-era limitation; it does not establish the mode’s later online-service status. NFL.com’s feature report quoted gameplay producer Clint Oldenburg saying, “We want to continue to blur the lines between our game and the real-life game.” That statement describes a development goal, not a review verdict.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Is Madden NFL 24 worth it?
It depends on what you want from the game. The review picture is more encouraging if your priority is on-field play or the specific additions to Superstar Showdown, Franchise, and Superstar. It is less persuasive if menu speed, mode variety, or a substantial year-over-year overhaul matters most to you. Compare the platform generation and included features before choosing a version: EA’s launch description tied several features to PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC, and the available evidence does not support a full technical comparison of every release.
Rank #3
- American football simulation game brings all the intensity and realism of NFL players, drafts, and strategies to your console - Game modes include Superstar: The League, Superstar: Showdown, Franchise, Madden Ultimate Team, and Cross-play for endless variation.
- Anatomically accurate player skeletons are more responsive, achieving true-to-life player motion during gameplay - Field SENSE animation technology provides greater control, realism, and immersive Ness when performing complex maneuvers.
- AI enhanced movement makes it easier for your team to execute your gameplan with ball carrier pathfinding and QB and DB awareness.
- Skill-based Passing 2.0 has improved accuracy, DB behavior, and catching for more intuitive throwing and defensive actions.
- Hit Everything 2.0 gives your teammates greater situational awareness, allowing them to push the pile and gain ground to attack the football more effectively.
Metacritic displayed retailer purchase options, but that does not confirm current stock, price, or a particular physical edition. Check the current listing for the platform, format, and availability you want.
Quick Recap
Best Value
Rank #4
- SAPIEN TECHNOLOGY – A leap forward in character technology introduces new anatomically accurate NFL player skeletons that are more responsive and true-to-life player motion.
- INCREASED CONTROL AND REALISM – The newest iteration of FieldSENSE provides an enhanced gameplay foundation giving you greater control and delivering realism to all the ways you play.
- YOUR STARDOM. YOUR STORY. – Achieve greatness in your NFL career with game-changing control. Select your position, body type and customize your Superstar and build your legacy.
- AI ENHANCEMENTS – Smarter AI enables smoother and more realistic player action and reaction to the plays you call, providing more confidence your AI teammates will execute your gameplan the way you intend.
- CROSS-PLAY – Connect with players across PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC, then show them what electrifying talent looks like.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
