Hardware FixRecommendedDevice not working? Your driver may be the problemCheck updates for common hardware issues.Fix DriversHalloween DealsAmazon USHalloween week deals: useful picks before month-endAmazon US: current deals, useful picks and tech finds.Check DealsWindows FixRecommendedWindows errors stealing your time? Find the fix fastScan stability, cleanup and performance issues.Fix Now×
VGSOURCES
Get listed

CastlevaniaPATCH 2026.10.17

What Makes a Metroidvania? Backtracking, Ability Gates, and Map Design Explained

By VGSources Team 9 min read

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

A Metroidvania is an exploration-focused action-adventure built around a connected world, routes blocked by current capabilities, and meaningful returns to places you have already visited. You gain an ability, item, or useful knowledge; that change lets you reinterpret an obstacle and reach a new branch. The label is flexible rather than a strict checklist, but the relationship between world layout, capability gates, and revisiting is its defining idea.

What is a Metroidvania?

The word combines Metroid and Castlevania, but it describes a design structure rather than a licensing category. In the narrow sense described by Axiom Verge creator Tom Happ, it is a side-scrolling action-adventure in a continuous map where obstacles can be overcome only after the player finds the appropriate items and backtracks. Broader usage includes games that keep the same underlying relationship between exploration and progression even when they differ in camera view, combat style, or movement system.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

A practical definition is:

  • Connected world: Regions form a persistent space rather than a sequence of wholly separate stages.
  • Capability-gated routes: An obstacle requires an ability, item, or knowledge that the player does not yet possess.
  • Meaningful revisits: Returning to a known location reveals access, rewards, shortcuts, story information, or a better route.

These features can be weighted differently. A game may contain many locked routes but little mandatory backtracking, or it may emphasize a large, interconnected map in which knowledge and route choice matter as much as newly acquired powers. Calling something a Metroidvania is therefore a useful description for players, not a legalistic test that every developer must satisfy.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

How the Metroidvania progression loop works

The genre turns progression into both character change and world reinterpretation. The route you could not use earlier was often physically present; your capabilities or understanding were inadequate. A typical loop looks like this:

#1 Best Overall
Sale
Hollow Knight - For Nintendo Switch
  • Classic side-scrolling action, with all the modern trimmings. Dodge, dash and slash your way through even the most deadly adversaries.
  • Tightly tuned 2D controls. Dodge, dash and slash your way through even the most deadly adversaries.
  • Forge your own path! The world of Hallownest is expansive and open. Choose which paths you take, which enemies you face and find your own way forward.
  • An enormous cast of cute and creepy characters all brought to life with traditional 2D frame-by-frame animation.
  • Leap into minds with the Dream Nail. Uncover a whole other side to the characters you meet and the enemies you face.
  1. Explore what is reachable. You move through the currently available regions, fight enemies, and inspect suspicious passages, unusual terrain, doors, or other obstacles.
  2. Record a limitation. You encounter a route that clearly cannot be used yet, or you recognize a place whose purpose is not obvious. The important information is that the obstacle remains in the world for later.
  3. Acquire a change in capability. A movement power, tool, item, or relevant piece of knowledge expands what the character can do. The exact form varies from game to game.
  4. Reinterpret the map. The new capability makes a previously seen obstacle understandable as an opportunity. A route may become traversable, or a new branch may open near the player’s current position.
  5. Return and collect the payoff. Revisiting a familiar area produces a connection, reward, shortcut, story detail, or access to a region that was previously out of reach.
  6. Update your mental map. You now know more about how the world fits together and can choose where to investigate next.

This loop is different from simply finding a key for a single locked door. In a Metroidvania, the new capability commonly has broader consequences: it can apply to several obstacles, change movement through old spaces, or create multiple possible routes.

What are ability gates?

An ability gate is an obstacle whose solution is a capability obtained during progression. The gate might be a gap that demands a new movement option, a hazard that requires a protective tool, or a surface that can be interacted with only after learning a specific technique. The defining feature is functional: acquiring the capability changes which portions of the world are accessible.

How to recognize a genuine ability gate

  • The obstacle is visible before the solution. The player can notice a blocked passage, strange surface, or otherwise suspicious route.
  • The later capability explains the earlier obstacle. When the player gains the power, its purpose is legible enough to suggest where it might work.
  • The capability has more than one consequence. It may open several routes or alter movement, rather than serving only as a one-use key.
  • Returning has a reason. The reopened location offers progress, a reward, a shortcut, information, or a meaningful choice.

Not every locked door is an ability gate. A conventional key, a story-triggered seal, a one-way exit, or an obstacle that exists only to pace a linear sequence can be useful design without making the game a Metroidvania. The category depends on how access, capability, and world structure interact across the whole game.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Why ability gates feel satisfying

A well-signposted gate creates a delayed moment of recognition: the player remembers an earlier limitation and understands why the newly acquired power matters. The satisfaction comes from solving a spatial problem as well as improving the character. If the obstacle is too ambiguous, players may not know what changed or where to apply it; if every gate is identical, progression becomes a checklist rather than an act of discovery.

Why do Metroidvania games make you backtrack?

Backtracking means returning to an earlier area after gaining a new capability or clue. It can make the world feel like a coherent physical place: a familiar chamber remains where it was, but its possibilities have changed. The return also lets designers reuse space in a way that reflects the player’s growth instead of discarding every area after one visit.

Rank #2
Hollow Knight - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
  • Classic side-scrolling action, with all the modern trimmings.
  • Forge your own path! The world of Hallownest is expansive and open. Choose which paths you take, which enemies you face and find your own way forward.
  • Evolve with powerful new skills and abilities! Gain spells, strength and speed. Leap to new heights on ethereal wings. Dash forward in a blazing flash. Blast foes with fiery Soul!
  • Equip Charms! Ancient relics that offer bizarre new powers and abilities. Choose your favorites and make your journey unique!
  • An enormous cast of cute and creepy characters all brought to life with traditional 2D frame-by-frame animation.

Backtracking becomes frustrating when travel repeats without discovery. The relevant question is not whether a game makes you revisit a location, but what the revisit provides and how costly the trip is.

Four tests for good backtracking

  • Payoff: Does the return reveal a branch, reward, shortcut, story detail, or useful route?
  • Travel cost: How much safe or empty territory must the player cross again, and does the game offer a sensible way to reduce that cost?
  • Memory support: Can players remember where the new ability might apply, either through clear landmarks or map notes?
  • Route choice: Do links between areas allow more than one sensible approach, or does every revisit force the same long corridor?

In a 2025-08-26 PC Gamer interview about Hollow Knight, co-director William Pellen said, “One of the things we were really keen on is getting as many connections between areas as we could.” Co-director Ari Gibson connected those links with making backtracking less frustrating. Their comments describe Team Cherry’s experience, not a universal rule: a different game can deliberately choose fewer connections if its rewards, pacing, and navigation make that choice work.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

How do Metroidvania maps work?

A Metroidvania map is more than a diagram of rooms. It supports a mental model of the world: which regions connect, which routes are blocked, what kind of change might open them, and how a new ability could alter an old path. The strongest maps preserve mystery while remaining consistent enough for players to reason about them.

Connectivity

Meaningful links between regions create loops and alternate approaches. A connection can shorten a later journey, provide an escape route, or let the player choose which region to tackle next. Connectivity does not mean every area must connect to every other area; it means the links that do exist have navigational or progression value.

Spatial coherence

Players should be able to form a believable sense of place. Distinct landmarks, consistent transitions, and understandable vertical or horizontal relationships help a familiar route remain recognizable. In the same PC Gamer discussion, Pellen described wanting the world’s spaces and transitions to make sense as a physical space. That is a design example, not a requirement that every Metroidvania imitate Hollow Knight.

Rank #3
Hollow Knight: Silksong Standard - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
  • Discover the fallen insect kingdom of Pharloom! Explore mossy grottos, gilded cities and misted moors as you ascend to the shining citadel at the top of the world.
  • Engage in lethal acrobatic action! Wield a huge suite of deadly moves as you dance between foes in swift, beautiful combat.
  • Craft powerful tools! Master an ever-expanding arsenal of weapons, traps, and mechanisms to vanquish your enemies and explore new heights.
  • Solve shocking quests! Hunt down rare beasts and solve ancient mysteries to grant the wishes of the downtrodden and restore the kingdom’s hope.
  • Face over 200 ferocious foes! Beasts and hunters, monsters and knights. Defeat them all with bravery and skill!

Progression legibility

A map can be mysterious without being arbitrary. Players need enough information to infer why a route is blocked and what kind of change may help. Visual language, enemy behavior, environmental clues, and the shape of an obstacle can all communicate that information without spelling out the answer.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Discovery versus guidance

Too much guidance turns exploration into following instructions; too little leaves players wandering through territory that has no current purpose. Effective maps let players notice possibilities, remember them, and make an informed choice about where to search next. A map interface may support this with markers, but the world itself should carry some of the explanation through landmarks and consistent rules.

Revisit payoff

An old area should gain value when a new capability changes the player’s options. The payoff need not always be a major upgrade. A shortcut, optional challenge, narrative detail, or safer route can justify a return when it is clearly connected to the earlier obstacle.

What the classic examples contribute

Super Metroid and Castlevania: Symphony of the Night are commonly cited because they combine a continuous persistent map, distinct regions, and progression tied to abilities or equipment. They demonstrate the family resemblance without defining a single mandatory template.

Example What it illustrates What it does not establish
Super Metroid Continuous-map exploration and ability-based access That every Metroidvania must copy its structure or presentation
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night Exploration combined with a large map and equipment-driven motivation That role-playing statistics, shopping, or equipment systems are required
Hollow Knight Interconnected regions, map connections, and exploration-focused revisits That Team Cherry’s particular map density is a universal standard

Koji Igarashi’s discussion of Symphony of the Night emphasizes a large map and equipment as reasons to explore. That context explains one branch of the genre, in which role-playing systems reinforce exploration; it does not turn those systems into genre requirements.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
Rank #4
HOLLOW KNIGHT [E10]
  • Includes four giant bonus content packs: Hidden Dreams, The Grimm Troupe, Lifeblood, and Godmaster
  • Classic side-scrolling action, with all modern trimmings
  • Tightly tuned 2D controls. Dodge, dash, and slash your way through even the most deadly adversaries
  • Explore a vast interconnected world of forgotten highways, overgrown wilds, and ruined cities
  • Forge your own path. The world of Hallownest is expansive and open. Choose which paths you take, which enemies you face, and find your own way forward
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

Where are the genre boundaries?

Genre labels describe overlapping design tendencies, so borderline cases are normal. A game can have a connected map but no capability-based progression, or it can use ability gates in a mostly linear sequence without asking the player to revisit a persistent world. Those features may make it adjacent to a Metroidvania rather than a clear example.

The label can also be applied more broadly than its historical side-scrolling association. Camera perspective, combat complexity, crafting, statistics, and shopping are secondary questions. The central test is whether exploration, changing capabilities, and the structure of the world continually affect one another.

Developers do not have to adopt the label. In the PC Gamer interview, Pellen offered a broad personal understanding: “All it means is a game set in a large, interconnected world.” Team Cherry also described avoiding decisions dictated solely by a genre category. This distinction matters because the features can be present even when a creator markets the game under another description.

A player’s checklist for identifying a Metroidvania

When deciding whether a game fits the term, ask these questions while playing:

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
  • Do regions form one persistent or meaningfully interconnected world?
  • Have you encountered routes that remain blocked until your capabilities change?
  • Does a newly acquired ability affect more than one situation?
  • Are earlier locations worth revisiting for access, rewards, shortcuts, information, or alternate routes?
  • Can the map and environmental landmarks help you remember where a capability may apply?
  • Does the game give you some freedom to choose what to investigate next, rather than moving through only isolated stages?

A “yes” to all six suggests the conventional core. A game can still be described as Metroidvania with a weaker answer in one area if the other relationships are unusually strong. Conversely, a collection of locked doors alone is not enough.

A designer’s framework for building the loop

For designers, the genre’s challenge is not merely placing powers behind obstacles. Each gate should participate in a readable chain from observation to acquisition to return.

  1. Show the possibility early. Let players see or sense at least some future routes so exploration has questions to answer.
  2. Make the capability distinct. The new power should change movement, interaction, or problem-solving in a way the player can feel immediately.
  3. Place several potential applications. Multiple candidate locations make the world feel systemic and give players route choice.
  4. Vary the payoff. Mix major progression with shortcuts, optional rewards, challenges, and narrative discoveries so every return is not identical.
  5. Control travel friction. Connections, landmarks, and other navigation support should keep the return leg focused on discovery rather than repetition.
  6. Test memory and inference. Watch whether players can explain what changed and identify plausible places to try it. Confusion may indicate a communication problem, while effortless completion may indicate that the gate is too obvious.

This framework also explains why a large map by itself does not create the genre. Without capability changes and worthwhile reinterpretation, size produces distance rather than exploration.

The clearest way to think about the genre

Metroidvania design makes the world part of progression. The character becomes more capable, but the player also becomes better informed about the world’s connections and rules. Ability gates create questions, backtracking tests whether the answers are rewarding, and map design determines whether those answers feel coherent or exhausting.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

An official PLAYISM developer roundtable captured the appeal this way: “Personally, I think exploring and gradually filling out a map is what most strongly makes me feel like I’m playing a Metroidvania.” The speaker is not identified in the excerpt, so the statement is best read as a player-facing perspective rather than a universal definition. It nevertheless points to the genre’s core experience: exploration gradually turns an unknown space into a navigable, possibility-rich one.

Quick Recap

SaleBestseller No. 1
Bestseller No. 2
Hollow Knight - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
Hollow Knight - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
Classic side-scrolling action, with all the modern trimmings.
$14.99
Bestseller No. 4
HOLLOW KNIGHT [E10]
HOLLOW KNIGHT [E10]
Classic side-scrolling action, with all modern trimmings
$33.39

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.

CastlevaniaGame DesignHollow Knightlevel designMetroidmetroidvania

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Recommended PC Tool
Recommended PC Tool
PC Slower Than It Used to Be?Free scan - under a minute
Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You DownFree scan - exact matches

Two free Windows tools

One Free Minute Could Fix That PC

Before you go - each of these free tools takes about a minute and tackles what quietly slows a Windows PC down.

Special offer. View Outbyte info, uninstall instructions, EULA, and Privacy Policy.