Dungeons 4 is a well-regarded, familiar-feeling strategy sequel: critics generally enjoy its dungeon-building and management, but some find its overworld combat underdeveloped and its changes from Dungeons 3 incremental. It is most appealing if you want more of the series’ established dungeon loop, not a major reinvention.
What the review scores say
On Metacritic’s PC critic page, Dungeons 4 has a 74 Metascore from 12 reviews, captured October 8, 2026: seven are positive, five mixed, and none negative. Metacritic’s product page shows a 7.8 user score from 30 ratings on the same date. That user-rating sample is small, so treat it as an indication rather than a broad consensus. Metacritic critic reviews Metacritic product page
Steam’s listing showed 84% positive from 1,209 English-language reviews on October 8, 2026. Its separate recent-review snapshot was 73% positive from 23 reviews. These figures use different samples and rating systems from Metacritic’s, and the recent-review window can change. They describe review sentiment, not sales or the size of the player base. Steam store listing
What critics like about Dungeons 4
The dungeon-management loop
Positive reviews describe an enjoyable dungeon manager and RTS built around managing resources and developing a dungeon. TheGamer’s review highlights the resource-management emphasis and challenge; GameSpace calls it a strong return for the series. Those are individual outlet assessments, but they reflect the sequel’s clearest strength: giving players a satisfying continuation of its established management formula. Metacritic critic reviews
#1 Best Overall
- Multiplayer! - Up to four players can team up offline or online and fight together in co-op mode.
- Power Up! - Unlock dozens of unique items and weapon enchantments for devastating special attacks.
- Options! - Personalize your character, then fight up-close and personal with melee swings, hang back with ranged attacks, or tank your way through swarms of mobs, shielded by heavy armour!
- Epicness! - Explore treasure-stuffed levels in a quest to take down the evil Arch-Illager!
- Over 12 million players LTD!
Approachable strategy and humor
Some critics find the strategy accessible and the humor effective. Neither response is universal: the game’s tone is part of its appeal for some reviewers, while others consider the writing or jokes dated or less successful.
What reviewers criticize
Familiarity rather than reinvention
Several reviews describe Dungeons 4 as iterative compared with Dungeons 3. That is not necessarily a problem if you want more of the same dungeon-management style, but it matters if your priority is a substantially new set of mechanics.
Rank #2
- Conquer unstoppable monsters - dark alliance pits players against some of the most legendary monsters from the world of dungeons & dragons - Frost giants, beholders, White dragons-muster the strength to defeat them all against insurmountable odds
- Fight alongside your friends - join up to four friends and fight together in a dynamic co-op experience with explosive real-time combat - unleash devastating combos as you topple unstoppable monsters too powerful to go it alone
- Play as one of four distinct heroes, each with their own unique playstyle and customizable abilities - complete missions and vanquish bosses to unlock new skills and earn powerful gear, allowing players to take on even bigger challenges
- Brave the frozen landscape - dark alliance brings to life the world of dungeons & dragons like never before - Explore the frigid and dangerous world of ice wind dale as you defend your homeland from armies of abominable monsters
Overworld combat and presentation
Reviewers also criticize the overworld’s RTS combat as underdeveloped or primitive, and some point to visual clutter. If battles outside the dungeon are a major part of what you want from a strategy game, these reservations deserve particular weight. Metacritic critic reviews
Is Dungeons 4 worth playing?
It is a reasonable choice for players who enjoy building and managing a dungeon and are comfortable with a sequel that refines a familiar formula. The case is weaker if you expect a major departure from Dungeons 3, polished or deep overworld battles, or humor that reliably lands for every player. The available reviews point to a split in emphasis, not a single feature that will suit everyone.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Rank #3
- Join the Adventure: Darkest Dungeon: The Board Game is a cooperative dungeon crawler for 1-4 players, where you complete missions and restore the Heir's mansion.
- Face the Darkness: Battle evil forces and overcome challenges as you explore the treacherous Darkest Dungeon.
- Game Components (2 boxes in 1 game!): The Core Game includes all cardboard/paper pieces, while the Strongbox contains detailed miniatures.
- Popular Origin: Based on the critically acclaimed video game by Red Hook Studios, which has sold over 8 million copies.
- Tabletop Transition: Experience the dark and immersive world of Darkest Dungeon now in a board game format.
Dungeons 4 vs. Dungeons 3: what to compare
Reviews characterize Dungeons 4 as iterative, but the available evidence does not establish a controlled, feature-by-feature comparison. If you are deciding between the two, consider what matters most to you:
- Dungeon building and management: Is continuing the series’ central loop enough, or are you looking for a substantial mechanical change?
- Overworld battles: How important is satisfying RTS combat outside the dungeon?
- Novelty: Would a familiar sequel feel welcome or too similar?
- Humor and writing: Reviews differ on whether the tone works.
- Platform features: Check the listing for the version you plan to play rather than assuming every platform has the same options.
Release, platforms, and listed features
Dungeons 4 was developed by Realmforge Studios and published by Kalypso Media. Steam lists its release date as November 9, 2023. Metacritic lists PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, and Nintendo Switch. Steam’s PC listing specifies single-player, online co-op, and a level editor; those details should not be assumed to apply identically to console versions. Metacritic product page Steam store listing
Quick Recap
Best Value
- 5-Minute Dungeon is the most fun you can have in 5 minutes! You'll need teamwork to defeat each dungeon in only 5 minutes, and then take on the next intense challenge. Defeat all 6 bosses to win!
- Now with 25 more cards and the extra-challenging Dungeon Master: Final Form boss!
- Featuring a free timer app for Android and Apple devices, with six different themed narrators!
- Easy to learn, quick to teach: Match your cards to each symbol in the dungeon deck to win! 5-Minute Dungeon is perfect for teams of 2-5 players aged 8+.
- Includes: 275 Cards, 5 Double-Sided Hero Mats (10 Heroes Total), 3 Double-Sided Boss Mats (6 Bosses Total)
Rank #4
- Experience the critically acclaimed dungeon Manager in its Full glory, including underworld dungeon sim, and overworld real-time strategy game, With several unforgettable characters in an epic tale of the everlasting fight between good & evil
- Contains expansion packs “once upon a time”, “evil of the Caribbean”, “Lord of the kings”, “clash of gods”, “an unexpected DLC”, “famous last words” and a new skirmish map Pack, as well as several Free content updates
- Size does matter: a total number of 50+ missions and more than 50 hours of playtime, randomly generated maps, a brand-new co-op mode for two players, competitive multiplayer, more rooms & monsters, and more unique abilities
- Speak (No) evil: the fan-favorite dungeons narrator is back with his unmistakable voice, continuing the dungeons Legacy in the best way possible
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
